Point & Figure Charting
Being interested in technical analysis for close to 60 years I read just about every book I could find in the library back in the sixties and early seventies on the subject. Naturally, that included point and figure charting. While interesting I never really pursued it and over the years when I have looked at some calls made by P&F chartists I never found them to be consistently accurate. Maybe too small a sample size or the particular practictioners weren’t that good? I just never found it all that useful. I do find from time to time when I look at a P&F chart on something I am researching, the chartists come up with very entertaining names for the various patterns. Case in point the recent gold chart. Apparently the P&F folk have labelled gold’s recent pattern as having a bullish “catapult”breakout on Thursday May 4th. That was the blowoff top and pullback day and so far there hasn’t been any catapult higher, yet. I find the terms amusing and entertaining but usually not very useful.
To ALL forum members … this guy is a troll and should be expelled.
This ‘poster’ with his handle, never and I repeat NEVER posted a charted chart (by his own), is now talking being into ‘chartology’ over 60 years, always says to buy but never support such statement with a charted chart.
The moderator should do his job as this poster is a troll and a fraud and should not be trusted. He gives unsupported BAD ADVICE as not everybody is able to think clearly. I think I not speak for myself.
IMO
Sir Nightingale,
For the last time, I’m asking you … how many “forums” or “fora” have you visited in the last 20 years, where you have not found people posting “opinions”, even on mathematical “things” such as technical analysis of charts or patterns or indicators?
People charting bowls have been ridiculed.
People with arc-patterns have been ridiculed.
Commodity-manipulation callers have been ridiculed.
What is it that you have to offer, that makes you NOT A TROLL?
And 99.5% of the rest of the stocks-PMs-commodities-investors-speculators-etc-etc attempters are ALL TROLLS in one way or the other?
GL
This is OUT of Line Nightingale !
Completely uncalled for . CM is simply opining on a Form of TA that is out of favor..Point and figure .
You may agree or disagree with Chartsmaster but he is a valued poster and NOT a Troll
He is one of us . His Views on World matters fit in with the consensus here. He trades and invests in Gold related Assets .
I dont always agree with him either and we have had our “spats” BUT this is totally uncalled for and deserves to be called out .
Instead of an attack …how about a chart ?
sheesh
Agreed. This post is relatively harmless…is it just there to opine as an authority on the subject of technical analysis?! No thanks. I’m with Nightingale. Let’s see some S&R lines, maybe a channel…check the ego at the door. How about we start flagging any post that exclaims “it’s your last chance to get on the train”, “rocket ship about to take off”, “rather be a day early”, “buy of a lifetime”, “micro stocks on the launch pad!” SHEESH!
Hermit go climb back into your troll shell as well.If you have a comment about a particular post, make it at that time. Why bother bringing up quotes out of context? Waste of everyone’s time. Regarding your and the first troll’s comments on technical analysis do you even know what it is? Analysis of a chart, NOT displaying a chart. As I have said before the major chart services do a much better job of producing charts then I and many posters(not all) do. So I stay in my lane and discuss my analysis of what the chart tells me. Anyone is free to disagree or add their take & I have always been open to that. What I don’t try to do is make charts, what for, so I can look like some whose charts are total nonsense to discern anything of value, or others that look like a child’s fingerpainting.
Maybe stop calling names and glean the important part of our message in the name of self-improvement. I agree, it’s some harsh criticism here, but you’re also not a child. It’s not hard to take a screen shot and upload the chart you’re looking at. Show us what your charting service can do. Make sure to give credit where credit is due. Refrain from exaggerated statements. If you’re not posting a chart, don’t make a directional call about a stock. It’s not helpful. The main problem I have is that the board is filled with this unsubstantiated ‘noise’ day after day. I could also look up in the stars, decide what they tell me and fill the board with directional calls. I’ll save everybody the misery. For reference, check http://www.rambus1.com. That guy is a master of his craft with many paid subscribers.
To better posting in the future. Cheers!
‘Instead of an attack …how about a chart ?’… haha. Funny.
That is the whole point. The guy never posts a charted chart. As a moderator for a (former) TA-site such should be MAIN focus. But this CM-guy is out of line and being utterly WOKE which is doing the opposite of what he/it is; saying being a ‘master’ but never follow through. Fully, you are being played!
And you say ‘he is a valued poster. Please enlighten me with ‘what value'(?) besides buy-buy-buy and his latest call is referring to what he said 1 year ago (as a clock is right twice a day) without giving a link to such statement of 1 year ago.
So this guy has 60 years of experience as he says) BUT NEVER posts a CHARTED CHART on this TA-site. So tell me, who needs to be called out?!
I am calling you out as you are protecting a WOKE poster. A TROLL!
One can see but remain BLIND.
Nightingale, I appreciate your charts. Your input is valued. Even on political matters. In spite of the arguments here, please stay on this forum.
Moron, do you even know what a Troll is, just look in the mirror. Nothing more needs to be said.
Hermit you have no clue what you are talking about. Once again technical analysis is analysis of the chart. Most of the time I include the chart. I also EXPLAIN the entry points and or support and or resistance often times the gaps on the chart and or the mvg averages that inform my opinion. Again, stop talking in generalities. When I post a chart where you feel something is either lacking or needs clarification please bring it to my attention but don’t waste our time with you nonsensical lecturing. Even in those cases where I don’t include a chart I provide the symbol so that anyone interested in considering what I post can put it into their chart or software and see if what I am saying makes any sense. I know that may be too hard from someone who contributes little but likes to criticize others.
I will say it one final time for someone who is both mentally deficient and clueless. Creating charts(while maybe a small component contributing to) is NOT technical analysis. Everyone here has access to charts and or charting software. It isn’t what I do, I don’t create charts I analyze them. That is technical analysis, along with other supporting data which I also often reference in my analysis.Why does everyone have to do something the way you choose to do it? If it isn’t what you want someone else is a fraud. Look at your own supposed work. Try making it more understandable and maybe try getting a call correct for once.