There’s More To Analyzing Gold & Silver Than Textbook Technical Analysis
As markets become more and more influenced by factors other than true price discovery(central bank interventions and especially outright price manipulation in gold and silver trading) one has to rely on fundamentals, sentiment and other factors in determining when to trade. The following paragraph from Michael Ballanger’s recent post captures the point. “However, because it was an “event-driven” takedown where capturing quarter-end profits was the obvious objective, I took the other side of the trade late Wednesday by wading into the iShares Silver Trust ETF (SLV:US) (that everybody hates) under US$20, (equivalent to US$21.55 for December silver) for a number of reasons but the main one was that every blogger and newsletter guru was looking at the double bottom just above US$22 and the island gap at $18 and assumed that technical analysis would prove foolproof. What they forgot is that breakdowns of support and resistance levels work in all markets around the globe except the gold and silver markets. In gold and silver, you buy “breakdowns” and you sell “breakouts” and the reason that you make this a rule of thumb is really quite simple. Technical analysis does not work in markets that are totally and completely rigged. (I learned that in 1979.)” I read this today but had similiar feelings and reasons for saying last week that I wanted to be “all in” silver by October 1st. The first short term downtrend line in silver has been broken to the upside and the longer, more important one will be broken once silver trades and holds above 23.50 or so where the 50 day mvg. avg. is quickly heading to.
I hear you CM ….But..
Rambus always says and has Proven thru the years that in spite of any “manipulation” or even because of it
The Gold market has the most symmetrical and beautiful patterns again and again.
He has proved the point by trading both ways exceedingly well.
manipulation if it is a factor ( and I think it is) …is also a repeating pattern which contributes to the sum total of what makes the charts.
It’s ALL in the Charts
“It’s ALL in the Charts”
And the charts are all about math.
If you’re not doing the math, you are lost or have false confidence.
PS … its not just price either. Volume matters.
Right now, for me, volume matters ALOT.
So … IMO it IS just about technical analysis.
But I tossed out the textbook a long time ago, and wrote my own.
PS … breakdowns and breakouts are NOT in my technical analysis vocab. At all.
Agree, it All shows up in the charts but if you wait until the chart reflects the turn you leave a lot on the table and there is nothing wrong with that. I have said before, many in the Tent buy breakouts and sell breakdowns(traditional technical anaysis) and that is fine, I anticipate which is why I am often early. If you get the fundamentals and sentiment and psychology right and don’t lever up, you can lose a little first, to make a lot later.
Good Stuff CM and pedro
Each of us has to find a comfort zone and find what works for us
It’s a personal thing
Yeah its in the charts but it is all bullshit. When you have vast powers you control the whole narrative. Gold and silver have been put in a box and the miners are getting flogged. The narrative is the Goldilocks scenery, not to high and not too low, just totally boring to keep interest out of the sector. Will they fail in the long run? Well that is to be seen.
No I don’t think it is “all in the charts”. Oh sure the price action does impute all known information into it, so in that respect one can say this, however one must properly analyze them and market psychology and sentiment is a critical element that I believe lead the charts
Agree with you Plunger “…market psychology and sentiment is a critical element that I believe lead the charts”