Their relative and absolute performance has been beyond terrible.  The fact that GDX is flat vs the junk bond ETF, HYG, over the last decade says it all.  SIL vs HYG is even worse.

While I always anticipated that 2023 could be challenging because of the absolute tail whipping the metals received in 2022 (that selloff kicked off a cyclical bear market), I can’t deny that the current chart picture has a VERY eery resemblance to the 2012-2013 top.  Then again look what happened in 2018-19.