SUNDANCE AT THE LAST REFUGE HAS A VERY VALID LOOKING THEORY
THIS GETS MY ATTENTION BECAUSE I LIVE IN AN AREA WHERE BASICALLY THE WHOLE ECONOMY IS DERIVED FROM HONDA IN ALLISTON ONTARIO
I AM GOING TO TRY TO PIECE TOGETHER THE THREAD FROM HIS X POSTS IN THE COMMENTS
STAND BY BUT HERE IS THE THEORY
. For about a year I have warned that Chinese auto manufacturers BYD and GEELY would take over shuttered auto plants in Canada.
Specifically, six months ago, against the backdrop warning of Stellantis, Toyota and Honda telling the Canadian government that without the USMCA they would shift auto production to the USA, I predicted BYD and GEELY would make moves on those closed facilities.
The move by China is easy to predict. Prime Minister Mark Carney has opened the door to Chinese EVs. It would be in Beijing’s best interest to retool and take control of closed plants to begin mass production in North America.
Chinese EV manufacturing in Canada serves two purposes.
First, they would not be limited in production to the cars that remain in Canada as part of the agreement. Factually, China would use their Canadian footprint as an export hub into Europe and save money on current distribution. Remember, Europe is losing their auto manufacturing base to China and Germany is laying off 100,000+ auto workers.
Second, the appearance of Chinese auto manufacturing in North America would put pressure on the United States to permit the cheap EVs to enter the market.
COMMENTERS
Shouldn’t U.S. companies step in and buy Canadian companies on the pennies if anything to keep China out of its sphere of influence? Why would they allow China to buy up in the scenario described here?
The Liberal/NDP/Bloc leadership is ( destroying us). It sickens me. Our prosperity is tied to America and they act like it’s not the case. It’s mind boggling. There are plenty of Canadians trying in vain to point this out to stubborn and thin-skinned Canadians not able to look past Trump.
SUNDANCE
Great question. However, you forget the seller has a voice in the exchange or sale. Canadians will willingly want China to buy their assets instead of Americans.
Why? Because the Canadian identity is defined by their main focus on ‘not being American.’ It’s all they know.
I can tell you specifically how it will materialize if you want, because I have already gamed this out. You might even make some money if you pay attention.
Toyota and Honda will do exactly what they have said they will do and exit Canadian manufacturing.
With full approval by Carney and the Canadian government, BYD and Geely will step in, purchase and take over those manufacturing plants to create vehicles in Canada (pennies on the CAD).
Canada will cheer because they will believe they just saved all those auto sector jobs. However, a few reality months later and suddenly it is all Chinese industrial operations bringing in Chinese workers to retool the factories.
Canada will end up paying unemployment benefits to Canadian workers, while Chinese factory workers prepare the facilities to manufacture BYD and Geely autos. The Canadian people will grit their teeth, yet do nothing because they accept their provincial government has already been corrupted by Chinese money.
See how that works?
AND
The only thing that shifted was Canada paying $350 million (bribe) to stop Honda’s CRV model exit from Alliston. [NOTE: Honda put $4 billion into USA] Other than that detail, check the prediction ?and contrast against current dynamics.
COMMENTERS
I agree with this sentiment. The weakness in the Canadian identity will be its undoing. Some of us see this playing out this way as well. Canada’s Laurentian elites are heavily connected in China. Canada is just a colony swapping masters. But millions of us are against it.
Another wow by Sundance:
“...the Canadian identity is defined by their main focus on ‘not being American.’ It’s all they know.”
but what good is the chinese plant in canada… who will buy the chinese evs in north america? At least europe has a population number that makes them a worthwhile market but canada is pretty small pop wise… do they think the US will buy them
And yet more reason to keep BYD, Geely banned in the US
SUNDANCE 2
2. I ran into a Chinese guy, professionally an actuary, in a hotel restaurant. He explained to me that China produces the BYD not to make money from the automobile, but rather to sell the carbon credits the automobile generates within the auto industry.
The actual value to Beijing is in selling the carbon credit worthiness to various automakers who are fined or penalized by their government for producing gasoline powered vehicles.
BYD is, in essence, not a car per se’, but a mechanism to generate a carbon credit certificate that can be sold to other car companies. It’s the carbon credit certificate that generates the revenue, not the sale of the vehicle. As my dinner guest explained, the auto insurance industry was having fits about this because the actuaries couldn’t accurately put a correct figure on the cost of the insurance warrantee within the industry (that’s another story).
The bottom line is that China is manufacturing a product to create a carbon credit certificate in response to the demand for carbon credits from all the world auto-makers. Any nation that has a penalty or fine attached to their climate goals is a customer. Those are nations with fines or quotas associated with the production of gasoline powered engines if the auto company doesn’t hit the legislated target for sales of electric vehicles.
In essence, EU/AU/CA/RU/ASEAN car companies buy Chinese car company carbon credits, to avoid the EU/AU/CA/RU/ASEAN fines. The Chinese then use the carbon credit revenue to subsidize even lower priced Chinese EVs to the EU/AU/CA/RU/ASEAN car markets, thereby undercutting the EU/AU/CA/RU/ASEAN car companies that also produce EVs.
SUNDANCE 3
3. Big Panda brilliantly exploits the ridiculous pontificating climate scam and has an interest in perpetuating -even emphasizing- the need for the EU/AU/RU/ASEAN countries to keep pushing their climate agenda.
China even goes so far as to fund alarmism research about climate change because they are making money selling carbon credit certificates on the back end of the scam to the western fear mongers. This is friggin’ brilliant.
My dinner buddy was in the business of identifying the cost/benefit equation between the climate change fines and the prices Big Panda could charge for the carbon credit certificates.
If, as an example, Brussels dropped the quotas for EVs, China would need to lower the price for the carbon credit certificates. So, Beijing wants Brussels to make sure they don’t drop the quotas. See how that works?
The climate change alarmists are helping China’s economy by pushing ever escalating fear of climate change. You just cannot make this stuff up.
What does the outcome look like?
Well, in this example we see thousands of unsold BYDs piling up in countries that emphasize climate regulations with no restrictions on the import of EVs (which most don’t even manufacture), which is almost every country. Big Panda doesn’t care about the car itself; they care about generating the carbon credit certificate to sell in the various carbon exchanges.
4. Put this context to the recent announcement by Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney about his trade deal with China to accept 49,000 EVs this year.
Prime Minister Carney bragged about getting the Chinese to agree to only super low prices for the Canadian market.
Mark Carney was very proud of his accomplishment to get much lower priced vehicles for Canadian EV purchasers. No doubt Big Panda left the room laughing as soon as Carney made his grand announcement.
1. China sells EV’s in Canada, creating credits available on the carbon exchange scheme. Europe et al will purchase the carbon credits because Bussels has fines against EU car companies.
2. With a foothold already established in Europe, China will then take the money generated by the carbon credit purchases and lower the prices of the Chinese EV cars sold in Canada.
It’s gets funnier.
3. Carney bragged about forcing China to only sell low price EV’s as part of the trade agreement. The low price of the EV’s in Canada will be subsidized by Europe. China doesn’t pay or lose a dime.
But wait….
4. Carney can’t do anything about the scheme he has just enmeshed Canada into, because Canada has a Carbon Credit exchange in law.
Big Panda wins again.
Volkswagen CEO warns German workers of sweeping layoffs to come
https://www.msn.com/en-us/autos/general/volkswagen-ceo-warns-german-workers-of-sweeping-layoffs-to-come/ar-AA2b6RCj?ocid=socialshare
As usual, nothing is quite like it seems on the surface.
And Sundance does his homework, and his thinking cap is not ornamental.
JUST IN THIS MOMENT
Carney just hinted that if Washington won’t deal on autos, Canada’s car industry could look to CHINA instead.
Asked if a failed U.S. deal gives him leverage with Beijing, he called it “action, reaction.”
His point: Canada has the workers and the factories, and if they aren’t fully used in North America, “that provides other opportunities.”
He’s already cracked that door open.
In January, Canada slashed its tariff on Chinese EVs from 100% to 6.1% for up to 49,000 cars a year.
He says it’s not leverage. But it sure sounds like a very loud hint.